fchan control panel
Thread List
Toggle Frames
Collapsible threads

[ f / m / h / s / toon / a / ah / c ] - [ artist / crit / b ] - [ dis / req / faq ] - [Manage]
[ Home / Rules ] - [ Chat: IRC / Web ]
[ Default ] [Dark] [Lite] [Only Images]

Posting mode: Reply

Painter: Width: Height: Source:

Art critique and advice; beginner artists are welcome to post here; includes an oekaki. (NO FLAMES)

Artists, read before posting!

Before you post your art to ask for critique, please read these tutorials. They explain the basic principles of drawing and figure drawing. Most posts where these basics are missing will never get a response, as people are quite frankly sick and bored of explaining over and over that you would have to pretty much learn how to draw first, before you could improve.

Courtesy of Arne Niklas Jansson: Basic and comprehensive drawing and painting tutorial
Courtesy of Bakaneko: Figure Drawing Basics, Further Anatomy, Hands

These were brought to my attention by Aeresque#Artist. Courtesy of Scribd: Drawing the Human head, Drawing Dynamic Hands, Dynamic Figure Drawing
And for those of you who want it a bit easier, we also have the whole thing as one neat rar with all three books in pdf form.

NEW! These were brought to my attention by MajorTom in #fchan. Courtesy of Andrew Loomis: Creative Illustration, Drawing the Head and Hands, Eye Of The Painter, Figure drawing for all it's worth, Fun with a Pencil, Successful Drawing, Drawing Dynamic Hands.

If you think you know a good basic tutorial that would fit in here, feel free to contact me under Xenofur in IRC and I will add the link.

(for deletion)

  • Supported file types are: GIF, JPG, PNG, SWF
  • Maximum file size allowed is 12000 KB.
  • Read the Rules Open DNP in a popup window. and check the DNP list Open Rules in a popup window..

reply to thread or open thread in full view thread contains a flash/ expand/shrink thread link to this post in full thread view
reply to this post in the quick reply window reply to this post in full thread view  report this post to the moderators

[-] [+] No.307
Any thoughts? 
File: WIP_conversation_by_Shmash.png -(236461 B, 800x600)
236461 No.307 307
Source: Shmash

Does anyone have any suggestions or general criticism on a couple fursonas I've been working on? Any would be greatly appreciated!

No.347 - Link Reply Report 347

Some of the hands look a little funky, but in general they look like an style unto themselves. The heads are an example of this. It's a very animator-friendly style.

File: Shmash_advice_final.png -(597389 B, 800x600)
597389 No.351 - Link Reply Report 351

This is the completed version of the picture

File: beachsample.png -(312043 B, 2200x701)
312043 No.357 - Link Reply Report 357
Source: shmash.deviantart.com

This is an example of when I draw in a less cartoon-like style... As you've said before I have problems drawing thin things like fingers or toes, all my hands come out stubby... Does anyone else have this problem or know of a solution?

File: beachsample.png -(298433 B, 2200x701)
298433 No.363 - Link Reply Report 363
Source: Shmash

Updated version of that based on input I received, It's rather sketchy looking because my vectorist hasn't gotten to it yet.

File: WIP_conversa-tweaked.jpg -(183723 B, 800x600)
183723 No.373 - Link Reply Report 373

Coloring is not my forte, but I'll give this a shot.

If you're going to go through the trouble of trying to make clothe folds, color them in instead of just smushing a flat line through the pants. Doesn't take much extra work to do it.

Gives it a little more life, that way.

No.381 - Link Reply Report 381

Can I ask what program/tools you used? Right now I'm a loser and only use SAI for my art...

No.415 - Link Reply Report 415

You need to brush up on anatomy and proportion.

Quite a few aspects of the most recent picture looked better in the first, but I will go off the second, assuming that's what you're working with.

The feet are entirely too small. They're generally about the length of the forearm (excluding hand), or about two thirds to three fourths the length of the calf (excluding knee and foot). The far one looks decent, probably a little too rounded and the toes might be too short. Given that there are drastic variations in toe size and shape I'd actually not worry about that one too much if I were you, unless you want her to have an overall slimmer foot.
The close one is very odd. The angle seems like it would be very uncomfortable. It would be more natural if it were facing away from us.
I would say, you probably have two feet on your body and you can probably see them enough to study and reference them while learning to draw feet. You will have to use outside sources too, since seeing a foot in all natural angles on yourself requires immense flexibility.

The calves are lacking calf shape and the bone in front is bending the wrong direction.

Knees look unnecessarily round and unknee like. Study these from real life if possible, photos will aid too.

Thighs should probably flatten out a little more near the top. It's a fairly fatty area on women and tends to deform whenever pressure is applied from any direction, including when she's lying front down on the ground.

Lines between the buttocks and thighs - at least where you have them - are unnecessary. The butt can still be fairly round but it connects to the thighs differently, more like an obvious separation of flesh rather than one continuous line with another line separating the two.

The hip area in the front is far too defined and round. The squishing out isn't so bad, but the line crossing over the thigh just adds a wrong definition to the whole thing, like the hip is some bizarre rounded thing sticking out of her.

Back is angled wrong, should have a more obvious s shape curve to it. Stomach should be flat against the ground, and the definition for the spine is too close to us.
Judging by how the breast is squished, I'd say it's fairly large. I'd also say from experience that laying on them on any surface that isn't soft as hell hurts. Maybe she's different, I wouldn't know, but it just looks uncomfortable.
Also, because her arm is raised I would suggest that the bulk of the fatty tissue of the breast would also be raised; it's too far down.

Study shoulders and all their deformations in various positions. There are photos everywhere of people with their arms in a bunch of different positions from a bunch of different angles. I realize a lot of people get shoulders wrong (I was royally jacking them up until some lulzy people pointed it out), and it would be very beneficial to study the musculature and how it actually looks on people.

I cannot quite figure out what's going on with the far shoulder.

Elbow seems oddly large and knobby, should be smaller and taper down at angles to meet at a rounded point.

The hand is... messed up I guess. Fingernails are pointing in opposite directions - probably something that would look 'wrong' in any case except where the hand is obviously in your face - and the way the hand is situated would be uncomfortable.

Skeletal structure, musculature, fatty deposits and how the flesh lays are all things you should work on if you intend on creating convincing creatures and characters.

Also, and I leave this last to mention because it's fairly arguable: the tail.
It seems unnecessarily high up, should be situated further down the buttocks, coming out from where the tailbone is.
The angle it's at also seems very uncomfortable, like it's gone and turned to an acute angle against the spine. It should generally remain obtuse. Even in animals with upward facing tails (house cats, dogs with curly tails) there's a smooth transition from the spine to that upward facing portion of the tail.

I may throw a redline over this because I feel I'm being somewhat vague and unhelpful.